Blue Square Pizza: Experience Exceptional New York-Style Pizza in Hopkinton

I went to Blue Square today for the first time and will definitely be going back. I had the New York and Detroit styles and they were both excellent!! The staff is super friendly also. It was the best pizza I have ever had! The crust was nice and crispy, great sauce and plenty of toppings. Give it a try! You will be glad you did!!

Excellent food with quality ingredients with a quaint atmosphere similar to the old NY pizza shops! I have tried several times to get to this pizzeria at the recommendations of friends but they have usually run out of pies when I have tried to order. Today I finally was successful. Some things to know: their menu though full of options, is not adjustable - you can’t make your own pizzas. They apparently get very busy (because they are so good) so they will run out so best to order early (can’t preorder online before opening but can order the day prior). So to the meal itself: we tried the vodka meatball and the pepperoni. Let me tell you - I have a very short list of pizzerias in MA that I like and this one bulldozed its way into it! Their ingredients are fresh and quality. Their dough is seasoned perfectly! Excellent consistency. I recommend ordering to go - we drove from Hopkinton to Upton and it was still piping hot. You want to visit this place but trust me when I say order early. I have tried for a year or two to finally get here & it was worth it. If you like pizza you want to eat here - soooo much better than the ever disappointing Regina’s that Bostonians have been manipulated into believing is good pizza. They get five stars from me !! I’m coming back!! My final rating is always based on the quality of food and the service. Environments vary and as a NYer, I grew up knowing that goldmine restaurants often have less than ideal environments bc of opportunity.

The Detroit style Pepperoni, Burrata, Hot Honey pizza is the best around. Their dough is a sour dough and tastes amazing and is nice and crispy like a Detroit style pizza should be. They use only the best ingredients. I highly recommend this restaurant. When it’s busy pizza can take a long time to make and it’s a little pricey, but for me, paying a couple dollars more for a pizza of this quality is worth it. It costs more because the quality ingredients cost more.

First timer at Blue Square, after a long day on the road (too late to cook). As a Neopolitan pizza snob, I was looking for something different, so I ordered the small Detroit style pizza with Burrata and Pesto. Lotta dough, but oh so tasty and the toppings were perfect! Perfect pesto with the freshest yellow, purple and red cherry tomatoes and actual burrata on top of a crispy edged pan pizza made from dough worth eating. Little more than I usually pay for pizza and it seemed like everyone had the same idea on this sultry summer Tuesday night (good luck finding street parking), but a delightful local surprise. Odd ordering by phone - sounded like I was chatting with an AI - but it efficiently texted me pizza order updates.

The pizza options are good — the crust is sourdough, which is unique and makes it feel less greasy than your usual pizza. My partner and I ordered a large detroit style pizza. The pizza itself is good, although barely worth the $30 we paid for it in my opinion. The center was delicious, but the crust was too hard and difficult to eat. The place itself definitely makes it seem like they expect people to order for takeout, which is what my partner and I did. I recommend ordering in advance — we ordered online and it was ready in forty minutes. Overall a decent experience, it’s a bit out of the way for us but I am curious to come back and try some of their other pizza styles.

Tried Blue Square Pizza for the first time. Went with a small NY style. Half pepperoni and half pinched sausage. Thought it was excellent. Nice crust, sauce had good seasoning. Will try a Detroit Style next time.

The pizza is always delicious! Perfect crust, just the right amount of sauce. The price is on the higher side, but totally worth it as an occasional treat.”

We drove a town over to experience this delicious and unique pizza! We got the Detroit style Soppressata and Hot Honey. The hot honey was not spicy even though they said that it is. The red sauce on top had a sweetness to it. I like the caramelized outside crust that was on all sides and even the bottom. Inside was soft and delicious. Then we got the New York style classic cheese, New York style mushroom truffle pizza and the Blue Square pizza. Depending how you like your crust the New York Pizza crust is very crunchy. All the kids after the first bite made comments like... Magnificent, satisfying, and wow! We ordered our pizza online and you want to make sure that you refresh with the update button to see the correct pickup time. Because when I was just refreshing the browser it kept saying 30 minutes but then when I hit the update button it jump to 70 minutes. I like how they have a TV screen and lets you know the progress and time until you have pizza's ready. It's accurate. Can't wait to return.